HomeNewsArticle Display

Unanimous Supreme Court ruling boosts Air Force’s effort to combat sexual assault

ARLINGTON, Va. (AFNS) --

In a unanimous ruling, the U.S. Supreme Court has reinstated rape convictions against three men in the Air Force, deciding that a lower military court improperly nullified the prosecutions and that the error was so stark that “resolving the question does not require lengthy analysis.”

While the case, United States v. Briggs, was arcane and narrow, the Dec. 10 ruling settled a troublesome legal question that required rape and sexual assault cases to be investigated, prosecuted and completed within a 5-year “statute of limitations” for cases originating between 1986 and 2006.

That narrow window, established by a now discarded 2018 ruling from the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces, differed from the current version of the Uniform Code of Military Justice, which, in 2006, made clear that for rape and sexual assault offenses, there are no statute of limitations. This parallels most civilian courts as well as provides victims time to decide what to do after such a traumatic event.

Though the Supreme Court specifically examined the role of the death penalty in the cases and its treatment under the UMCJ, the Court acknowledged that a longer period of time is the correct constitutional approach given the difficulties inherent in rape cases.

“The trauma inflicted by such crimes may impede the gathering of the evidence needed to bring charges,” Justice Samuel Alito wrote in the decision. “Victims may be hesitant for some time after the offense about agreeing to testify. Thus, under current federal law, many such offenses are subject to no statute of limitations.”

As a result, the Court restored rape convictions against Lt. Col. Michael Briggs, Lt. Col. Humphrey Daniels and MSgt. Richard Collins, all Air Force personnel who had been convicted in separate cases.

“The three offenders whose cases were decided by the Supreme Court will not have their lawfully-obtained convictions and sentences erased by the technicality” as directed by the Court of Appeals of the Armed Forces, Air Force chief prosecutor, Col. Shaun Speranza said.

“Their punishments will be restored, as should their victims’ faith in our dedication to justice,” he said. Speranza’s attorneys from the Air Force Government Trial & Appellate Counsel Division played an instrumental role supporting the case, working closely with the U.S. Solicitor General’s office which argued the case before the Court.

While the Supreme Court’s focus was limited to three known cases across the 20 years in question, Speranza said the emphatic ruling carried a broader significance in the effort to combat sexual assault and violence in the Air Force and across the entire military.

“The Supreme Court decision in Briggs effectively closes the window on military sexual offenders escaping prosecution under the Uniform Code of Military Justice due to the date of their crimes,” he said. “Now, no matter when the alleged rape occurred after 1986 or when the victim has the courage to report the offense, we can exercise criminal jurisdiction over the accused service member.”

Harmony Allen is the human face of the legal complexities and trauma at the core of the case.

Allen was raped and beaten by Collins in 2000, when both were stationed at Sheppard Air Force Base, Texas. She was 19. Collins was not only her superior but also her instructor in her coursework to become a radiology technician. 

Collins was convicted in 2017 and sentenced to 16 ½ years in jail. But Collins appealed and won because the conviction came seven years after the rape. The verdict was set aside and his sentence erased. He was released after serving two years.

“To get that justice, yes, it did restore my faith that there is still justice,” she said in an interview. “Yes, I feel it’s justice.” 

The outcome of the case, she said, “has huge implications” for the larger efforts across the military to address sexual assault. It also means that Collins must serve the remainder of any sentence. 

Allen said she believes the Court’s decision will encourage additional efforts to attack the problem across the military and build on the progress that’s been achieved to date.

Addressing sexual assault and sexual harassment has become a major focus in the Air Force and across the entire U.S. military.

Secretary of the Army Ryan McCarthy, for example, made leadership changes following an independent review of incidents at Fort Hood, Texas triggered by questions and concerns from the family of Army Spc. Vanessa Guillén and by Congress following Guillén's disappearance and murder. A task force was also formed to examine issues identified in the report.

Allen said she sees change that gives her reason to hope.

One major advance came seven years ago when Congress directed the military to establish the Special Victims’ Counsel (SVC) Division to represent and advocate for victims of sexual violence. The assistance is often provided by military lawyers who are charged with vigorously representing and protecting the interests of their clients.

The program ensures that victims are fully informed of their options and rights at every stage of a case, helping them make informed decisions throughout the process, and ensure their desires are communicated and respected. The attorney also works to “maximize victim privacy, minimize the impact of the process on their personal and professional lives, and ensure dignity and respect for the client.”

More directly, one SVC official said, “we advocate for whatever outcome the victim desires as long as it is legal and ethical.”

Allen said having an SVC was crucial. 

“She sat beside me and represented my rights. Without my SVC team, I would have been completely lost and alone,” Allen said. “Every time I called she always picked up the phone.”

In the Air Force, 49 SVCs represent approximately 1,000 sexual assault victims at any time. The unit, which by design is independent, averages nearly 2,000 cases each year.

Engage

Twitter
RT @HQUSAFEAFAF: #DYK the air terminal ops center (ATOC) at Nigerien Air Base 201 is responsible for air transportation ops including cargo…
Twitter
Since the beginning of the coronavirus pandemic, researchers have been working as quickly as possible to crack the… https://t.co/srH7dpHM8k
Twitter
.@GenCQBrownJr & @cmsaf_official receive their #COVID19 vaccines. Prioritized @DeptofDefense personnel are highly… https://t.co/tAhlWH4BQP
Twitter
RT @cmsaf_official: The culture we need in our Air Force is one where we embrace diversity, value respect, and foster inclusion. Team Dov…
Twitter
RT @GenCQBrownJr: Talk about a year to be proud of! @HQ_AFMC #Bestof2020AF https://t.co/jyXWj9iWcY
Twitter
Combatting COVID one arm at a time. Airmen from the 133rd Airlift Wing received their first dose of the Moderna… https://t.co/tojuYTsqXn
Twitter
Training for the fight A 21st Special Operations Squadron CV-22 Osprey takes off during a training mission at… https://t.co/b3hWLilMl8
Twitter
RT @AFResearchLab: Our team is using the power of directed energy and the electromagnetic spectrum to give our warfighters the upper hand.…
Twitter
RT @AFResearchLab: The @usairforce Golden Horde Vanguard program completed its first flight demonstration of collaborative weapons last mon…
Twitter
Give @GenCQBrownJr a follow for the latest on how he's leading the charge to accelerate change throughout the… https://t.co/vef2RqG6oy
Twitter
Developing civilian Airmen The Department of the Air Force is providing developmental education, academic programs… https://t.co/md3EPKRWvM
Twitter
RT @AirmanMagazine: It's time to vote for Airman Magazine’s 2020 photo of the year! This annual competition showcases the men and women of…
Twitter
Mentorship As part of service-wide focus on #mentorship, the @AETCommand Mentoring Council will virtually host a L… https://t.co/SPyI9QWbeN
Twitter
🚧 🚧 CAUTION: Falcons at work 🚧 🚧 F-16 Fighting Falcons based in the @CENTCOM area of operations conduct armed ae… https://t.co/bJO9eInx9u
Twitter
RT @AETCommand: #COVID19 vaccines continue to rollout & the logistics and immunizations teams at the 59th Medical Wing are ensuring the dis…
Twitter
Rolling out the #Vaccine in the phased plan per @DeptofDefense guidelines. https://t.co/NvPYGfourn
Twitter
It is tradition for senior leadership to present Airmen with a coin for exceptionally demonstrating the #AirForce c… https://t.co/qYrBJDfBuI
Twitter
Give @GenCQBrownJr a follow for the latest on how he's leading the charge to accelerate change throughout the… https://t.co/xmiFBLktWW
Twitter
RT @AFResearchLab: @cubcrafters XCub aircraft made a stop in Dayton as it heads over to Maryland to help our 711 HPW test their LASH system…
Facebook
The newest Air Force Podcast recently dropped. Listen to a small snippet of CMSAF Kaleth O. Wright talk with Staff Sgt. New about resiliency. Listen to the entire podcast on Youtube: https://go.usa.gov/xpnAD or Subscribe to The Air Force Podcast on iTunes: https://podcasts.apple.com/podcast/the-air-force-podcast/id1264107694?mt=2
Facebook
Our mantra, "Always ready!" It's the spirit we fly by! #B2Tuesday
Facebook
Need some motivation to get your week started off right? Listen as CMSAF Kaleth O. Wright weighs in...
Facebook
The U.S. Air Force Academy gives its cadets some unique opportunities. Ride along one of this opportunities.
Facebook
A United States Air Force KC-135 Stratotanker refuels an F-22 Raptor over northern Iraq, Nov. 6, 2019. U.S. Central Command operations deter adversaries and demonstrate support for allies and partners in the region. (Video by Staff Sgt. Daniel Snider)
Facebook
Although the Silver Star is the third-highest military medal, it's not given often. Today, TSgt Cody Smith was the 49th Special Tactics Airman to receive this medal since Sept. 11th, 2001. Read more of TSgt Smith's amazing story: https://www.airforcespecialtactics.af.mil/News/Article-Display/Article/2024815/special-tactics-airman-battled-through-injuries-awarded-silver-star/fbclid/IwAR2LZWwx1VHdTnQe39rIEBOuJS_0JvMQBBGt7I-E6zsxxn-Lx9387yu43Bc/ Cannon Air Force Base Air Force Special Operations Command United States Special Operations Command (USSOCOM) U.S. Department of Defense (DoD)
Facebook
Tune in as our Air Force musicians along with other military musicians are awarded the National Medal of Arts.
Facebook
Like Us
Twitter
1,311,730
Follow Us