Official Site of the U.S. Air Force   Right Corner Banner
Join the Air Force

News > Commentary - Have courage, speak up
Have courage, speak up

Posted 5/13/2013   Updated 5/13/2013 Email story   Print story

    


Commentary by Col. Daniel Higgins
2nd Bomb Wing Staff Judge Advocate


5/13/2013 - BARKSDALE AIR FORCE BASE, La. (AFNS) -- Recently, I saw a commercial depicting what appeared to be a typical business meeting. An older man, clearly the boss, said something along the lines of "So, we all agree -- it's a good idea?" To which an employee responds "I think it's a stupid idea."

In the next scene, the employee who gave his opinion is out on the street with a box of personal belongings, the implication being that he was fired for speaking his mind.

I don't recall what the commercial was trying to get me to buy, but whatever it was, I don't need it. In fact, in the Air Force, we need the opposite. It takes courage to serve in the Air Force. Yes, obviously it takes great physical courage.

All Airmen, regardless of rank or career field, can find themselves suddenly and without warning in harm's way, whether deployed to a combat zone or "safely" back at home station. Physical courage is expected; it's part of the deal we made when we volunteered to serve. And I think everyone understands that.

But there's another type of courage that Airmen need: moral courage.

Airmen need the courage to do the right thing when it might not be the easy thing. They need the courage to speak up and identify an issue or a problem when everyone else thinks things are going great.

Leaders, regardless of rank, need the courage to face their daily challenges and make the decisions necessary to accomplish the mission. Every decision involves risk; and while effective leaders can and should mitigate that risk to the extent possible, they can't eliminate it entirely.

Leaders understand that if you make enough decisions, sooner or later you'll make one that turns out to be wrong. Effective leaders get that and they find the courage to make the decision anyway. They take in the information available to them, weigh their options, mitigate the risk where possible, but they act with confidence and persistence.

But truly effective leaders also want to hear when they are on the wrong path. In fact, I would argue that they need to hear it when they are on the wrong path. Being a good Airman requires, by definition, that you also be a good wingman -- and being a good wingman means speaking up when necessary. As my Army friends would say, the time to hear I'm about to walk into a chopper blade is before I walk into the chopper blade. After-the-fact is not helpful at all.

As a leader, I value the members of my organization who are willing to speak up with a different viewpoint. They have the courage to offer their views, understanding that they may not be popular. They may even be wrong, but they offer them up anyhow because they know it makes for a better decision.

We all bring different experiences and backgrounds to the problems we face and those different experiences influence the way we view and solve problems. Those differences are what make the Air Force such an effective organization.

There is no monopoly on good ideas; they can come from anywhere and anyone in your unit. If you are the leader, cultivate a climate of openness that encourages your subordinates to speak freely and offer alternatives and suggestions for how to better accomplish the mission. If you're a follower, speak up!

You've got to be willing to say, "I think it's a stupid idea," when it is. Be respectful of course, but it doesn't do anyone any good for you to say, "Yeah, I thought we were on the wrong path, but I didn't want to say anything." That's not courage. That's not helpful to the organization. That's not being a good wingman -- or a good Airman.



tabComments
5/21/2013 4:05:14 PM ET
The only moral courage needed in the Air Force is for leaders to accept the input or critique of their subordinates at face value.The issue is not nor has it ever been an unwillingness on the part of juniors to raise questions. The issue is whether the leader being questioned has the integrity to check his ego and deliberate the question objectively.
Old Bear, Alaska
 
5/20/2013 9:36:26 AM ET
Have courage speak up. That makes it easier for Air Force leaders to decide who to get rid of when it comes time to recommend promotions. Stand up speak up and look for another job.
Don, Oklahoma
 
5/17/2013 10:15:25 PM ET
It seems from the commenting that an accompanying article directed at leadership could be written titled Have courage listen upStill I'm apparently in the minority who has been blessed with pretty willing and open leadership from day one. Yes there were a few who were a little more challenging to understand and henceforth manage but I can honestly say in my 12-yrs that I've only seen one maybe two leaders who refused to listen to dissenting opinions or new ideas. Though I recognize that that's just my experience - everyone has their own and I certainly do not mean to dismiss your perspective but instead hope to understand it so that I can be a better leader whenif that day comes.
David S., Robins AFB
 
5/16/2013 5:42:39 PM ET
As a manager in a global firm we deal with this as well. The important thing is the concept of time and place. When you are under a serious time constraint there isn't a lot of time for debate or discussion. And definitely asking for a private conference is much better in most cases. The boss may have a reason for doing something that cannot be discussed in an open forum.As mom always said there is a time and place for everything. Knowing the difference is key.
MSgt FV retired, Ireland
 
5/16/2013 12:33:56 PM ET
The reality is more like I thought you were on the wrong path and so did everyone else. We voiced our concerns and you said it was whining and we had to learn to follow the chain of command. So now you are in this mess which we accurately predicted and you are blaming us because you think we implemented your idea wrong. Yep that's how it is.
Peanut Brittle, bottom of the totem pole
 
5/16/2013 10:30:12 AM ET
Some leaders take counsel others do not. Some leaders take counsel if their decision will negatively impact themselves if it negatively impacts others they do not especially a civilian.
career civilian, midwest
 
5/16/2013 9:00:21 AM ET
I see this as written from the aspect of a Flag Officer tell the E-1 who asks a question and gets scolded by a superior infront of his so called co-workers and be ridiculed for asking a so called stupid question. so is this the difference between a correspondence course and actually taking an in-house course. Human contact e-mail is not the way to lead ONE PUSH UP AWAY FROM THE DESK. That is all carry on and carry out the plan of the day.
Dual Airman , FL
 
5/15/2013 4:17:34 PM ET
Colonel with all due respect there's no shortage of individuals with the type of courage you mention who are willing to speak up when necessary. There is however a definite shortage of leaders with courage who are willing to listen. In today's AF hubris has replaced true leadership. Twice this week already I've witnessed two incidents of individuals being publicly scolded by the boss for attempting to do just what you mention. The lesson learned by these individuals is that doing their job of tactfully presenting clear and well reasoned ideas and alternatives is only acceptable if they give the answers the boss wants to hear.
ksmith, CONUS
 
5/15/2013 10:58:35 AM ET
In my AF career I only had one supervisor who not only spoke his mind but also encouraged those who worked for him to speak up as well. He wasn't popular with some both above and below him but he did make Colonel before he retired. The AF needs more like him.
JD, Oklahoma
 
5/15/2013 10:55:41 AM ET
Persons in leadership positions are unique rarely are any two alike. To some the skills required come naturally others have to learn them and others have no business being in that position to begin with.Leadership styles are also very unique and members of an organization have to quickly learn and understand their leader's style. Some are authoritarian some are undecisive and some are in between.Once that is understood you'll know if and when stating a...differing viewpoint...is acceptable. Firing a shot across the Boss's bow in a meeting because you have moral courage is probably not be the best decision. Asking for a personal meeting with the Boss afterwards...again based on your knowledge of their leadership style...is probably the better approach.Your input may or may not be accepted or even appreciated but you won't be perceived by others in the unit as trying to undermine the Boss's authority.
Gen Halftrack, USA
 
5/15/2013 7:07:45 AM ET
That separates the warrior leaders from the politician leaders. Warriors listen to all criticism without reprisal the politicians carry on the status quo. The AF desperately needs warrior leadership.
Bruce, IN
 
5/14/2013 7:23:16 PM ET
With all due respect to the Colonel it will be nice if all the leaders had thick skin let alone maturity these days. I have seen 2 leaders in my short 14 years in the service that will meet and fit the Colonel's description and several thatlet us say not. I truly agree with Mr. Needleman he could not have said it better. Some who listen to your professional objections tend to smile and move on with their agenda. It is a different AF today Sir.
PT n Bake Sale Warrior, Realistan
 
5/14/2013 1:15:19 PM ET
As a grumpy old man I felt free to express myself and never really had any issues as a result of doing so. Sure there were some interpersonal issues because I stomped all over other people's personal agendas but that's expected. The thing is I felt free to express myself through my entire career.Until I made TSgt my enlisted evaluations pretty much all contained communication markdowns because I didn't know when to keep my trap shut.The USAF that I served in is nothing like the one you are trying to sell.
Retired SNCO, Greener pastures
 
5/14/2013 11:37:40 AM ET
...truly effective leaders also want to hear when they are on the wrong path. Call me crazy but if this is true I think we're really short on truly effective leaders. Even on the medical side our leaders tend to smile and nod and ignore all feedback.
SSgt , Texas
 
5/14/2013 11:21:04 AM ET
@Otis R. Needleman...not true...I am a Colonel and a Line officer and have spoken up still do when I feel wrong decisions are being made. If presented correctly objections to leadership decisions won't harm your progression.
Col_Line Officer, Somewhere South
 
5/14/2013 9:29:14 AM ET
Sir -- Any leader that is as open to honest criticism as your articlerecommends is a truly one of an extreme minority. In the opinion of oneover-baked Major honesty can have negative second order effects on a careerdespite exceptional performance. I wish more military leaders had themindset that you describe in this article. If they did our end of yearspending frenzies would have ended many years ago. Nevertheless I willmarch on with a purpose not to treat others as I have been treated but Imust declare that my experience tells me what you describe is not the norm.
Realistic, Remote
 
5/13/2013 10:15:03 PM ET
It appears that you and I serve in vastly different Air Forces.
Sgt whoever, conus
 
5/13/2013 8:43:49 PM ET
Nice thoughts and sentiments colonel but you are a colonel and a non-line officer. Try bucking the system as a line lieutenant or a captain and you'll never even see field grade. Your AF career will be very short and unpleasant. Not even PT and bake sales will save you.
Otis R. Needleman, Reality
 
Add a comment

 Inside AF.mil

ima cornerSearch

tabSubscribe AF.MIL
tabMore HeadlinesRSS feed 
CSAF to sponsor 3 captains for PhD program

Davis-Monthan Airmen work to end veteran homelessness by 2015

Jennies to jets to stealth: Bomb wing turns 90

Concentration camp survivor to fighter pilot: 'Freedom a beautiful thing'  5

Wounded warriors adapt, overcome at Andrews sports camp

Pilots, combat systems officers may be eligible for retention incentives   2

Alert Reaper Airmen find IED  1

Luke AFB F-16 crashes, pilots safely eject  4

AF drops 50,000 plus gallons of retardant on Colorado fires

352nd SOG welcomes Osprey to fleet

SecDef: DOD welcomes Supreme Court decision  37

Weather warns warriors, saves services silver  1

Squadron's lone female gunner aims high  4

Flight engineer reaches combat sortie milestone  4

tabCommentaryRSS feed 
Our commitment, our community

'Lucky' people take personal responsibility for their own success  16


Site Map      Contact Us     Questions     USA.gov     Security and Privacy notice     E-publishing  
Suicide Prevention      Sexual Assault Awareness & Prevention     FOIA     IG   EEO