HomeNewsArticle Display

Friendly fire hearing officer recommends against courts-martial

BARKSDALE AIR FORCE BASE, La. (AFPN) -- The two Illinois Air National Guard F-16 Fighting Falcon pilots implicated in a deadly "friendly fire" incident last year should not face courts-martial, the investigating officer's report said.

Majs. Harry Schmidt and William Umbach, of the 170th Fighter Squadron, face a variety of charges stemming from the April 17, 2002, incident that killed four Canadian soldiers and injured eight others near Tarnak Farms, Afghanistan.

Schmidt reportedly dropped a 500-pound bomb on the Canadians, who were conducting night training. The two faced a Uniform Code of Military Justice Article 32 hearing in January to determine if there was enough evidence to proceed to court-martial.

Col. Patrick Rosenow, the Article 32 hearing officer investigating the charges, has concluded that there is sufficient evidence to charge each pilot and try him by court-martial. However, Rosenow's non-binding recommendation is that disciplinary action be handled through administrative action.

Specifically, Rosenow's report recommended that Schmidt's case be considered in a non-judicial or administrative forum in lieu of trial by court-martial, and that Umbach's case be considered in an administrative forum in lieu of court-martial.

Rosenow asserted that the interests of good order and discipline could adequately be addressed by sanctions other than trial by court-martial.

Lt. Gen. Bruce Carlson, 8th Air Force commander and the general court-martial convening authority, will review the report and advisory recommendations before deciding on each case. His options include referral of some or all of the charges to court-martial, non-judicial punishment, administrative sanctions, or dismissal of some or all of the charges with no further action.

Schmidt had been charged with four counts of involuntary manslaughter, eight counts of assault, and dereliction of duty by failing to exercise appropriate flight discipline and failing to comply with the rules of engagement in Afghanistan.

Umbach faces the same charges besides an allegation that he, as flight commander at the time, failed to ensure that Schmidt complied with the rules of engagement.

Engage

Facebook Twitter
RT @USAFHealth: #TBT: Air Force medics, Eighth Army Soldiers, and Korean civilians load a wounded Soldier from the 1st Cavalry Division ont…
RT @AFRLScholars: Let's #celebrate a successful #AFRLScholar2019! With 350+ interns across 6 @AFResearchLab technical directorates and @AFW
RT @US_Stratcom: #DyessAFB #Airmen put their strength to the test as they competed in the 2019 #GlobalStrikeChallenge. @AFGlobalStrike #Kn
RT @AF_WBB: Get hype for season ⚡⚡⚡ https://t.co/a1nSjTx1Xc
RT @AstroHague: Each time I open the door the views keep getting better. Congratulations to all involved in the successful execution of thi…
RT @AETCommand: Last week, over 400 #Airmen came to San Antonio from bases around the world to learn more about the @usairforce mission of…
RT @DeptofDefense: Don’t look down. @usairforce cable & antenna systems airmen climb a tower during training at Aviano Air Base, Italy 🇮🇹.…
RT @ulalaunch: MISSION SUCCESS! United Launch Alliance's #DeltaIV has deployed #GPSIIISV02 Magellan for the U.S. Air Force Space and Missil…
Since Aug.1, 1948. @RealAFOSI has been #USAF's major investigative service, providing criminal investigations and… https://t.co/pKmUbamHWD
RT @AFSpace: Captain Rachael Preslar, a #TeamBuckley Panther, is the first active duty female to win Mrs. Colorado! She currently serves as…
RT @WrightPattAFB: “With the new system, we will have six times the processing power as Thor.” -- Air Force looking to improve weather data…
RT @ulalaunch: The countdown has begun for this morning's #DeltaIV rocket launch of #GPSIIISV02 for the @USAirForce and @AF_SMC. The launch…
RT @ulalaunch: Weather forecasters from @usairforce @45thspacewing say conditions are favorable to proceed with tower roll and for the rest…
RT @HQUSAFEPA: #APFKenya continued yesterday with tactics techniques and procedures on tactical combat casualty care and 5-line call for fi…
RT @StripesCarlos: Only 2 months in #Okinawa, @KadenaAirBase Airman helps save a 4-year-old boy from drowning at the beach... Read more of…
RT @AirForceMag: .@HQUSAFEPA this week kicked off its premier training and engagement event, the African Partnership Flight, at Laikipia AB…
RT @AFThunderbirds: **Update** Air Force Thunderbirds to Join Royal Air Force Red Arrows, F-35s & F-22 in Historic Aerial Parade over the…
RT @AF_Academy: The 68th Rescue Squadron spent time with USAFA cadets in the Ops Air Force program while jumping out of aircraft in #Arizon
RT @F22DemoTeam: BREAKING NEWS: We are excited to announce that we will be joining the @AFThunderbirds, @rafredarrows, and @thef35 Demo Tea…
RT @GenDaveGoldfein: Flew from RAAF Williamtown to Canberra by way of 2SQN Wedgetail w/ #AusAirForce. Absolutely impressed by the crew’s pr…